Freelance writer 
A federal judge in Boston has ruled that the lawsuit filed by migrants flown from Texas to Martha’s Vineyard
A federal judge in Boston has ruled that the lawsuit filed by migrants flown from Texas to Martha’s Vineyard in 2022, known as the Martha’s Vineyard flights lawsuit, can proceed against the Florida company that transported them. The lawsuit, filed by three migrants from Venezuela and an immigrant rights group, alleges that Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, his administration, and the air transport company, Vertol, conspired to mislead them and deprive them of their civil rights.
Claims Against DeSantis Dismissed in Martha’s Vineyard Flights Lawsuit
However, the judge dismissed claims against Governor DeSantis and other officials named in the suit. The dismissal was based on jurisdictional concerns, but it was done “without prejudice,” meaning that the migrants’ legal team can seek to bring DeSantis and others back into the case as it progresses.
Allegations of Deception and Civil Rights Violations in Martha’s Vineyard Flights Lawsuit
The migrants, identified as Yanet, Pablo, and Jesus, say they were told they were being flown to Massachusetts but only learned their final destination was Martha’s Vineyard shortly before landing. They allege that a videographer hired by the DeSantis administration recorded them arriving and boarding vans, but no one in Martha’s Vineyard, apart from the videographer and van drivers, had any advance notice of their arrival.
Judge’s Strong Words for Defendants in Martha’s Vineyard Flights Lawsuit
In her order, U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs criticized the defendants, stating that they were not legitimately enforcing any immigration laws. She expressed disbelief at the purpose of rounding up highly vulnerable individuals on false pretences and injecting them into a divisive national debate. The judge’s 77-page filing reflects her condemnation of the defendants’ actions.
Moving Forward with the Martha’s Vineyard Flights Lawsuit
The lawyers for Civil Rights, representing the migrants, hailed the ruling as a major victory. They emphasized that the decision sends a crucial message: private companies can and will be held accountable for assisting rogue state actors in violating the rights of vulnerable immigrants through illegal and fraudulent schemes.
The ruling by Judge Burroughs allows the Martha’s Vineyard flights lawsuit against Vertol to proceed while leaving open the possibility of including Governor DeSantis and other officials back into the case. The case highlights the plight of migrants who were allegedly deceived and deprived of their civil rights, emphasizing the importance of accountability and justice in immigration matters.
